Imagine you – you did everything right. You waited. You filled out the papers. You answered the questions. You pledged allegiance. You became a citizen of United States. You believed you had joined the club. You believed citizenship meant you were safe.
And then: poof. Someone upstairs decides you weren’t good enough after all. Someone digs out something old, something negligible, something they say changed your status. They rip your certificate, snatch your rights. Suddenly you’re a “former citizen.” Your home becomes an alien land.

This isn’t fiction. According to reporting by the Associated Press, naturalized citizens in the U.S. are increasingly wary of denaturalization policies under the guise of “immigration enforcement” — effectively undoing the contract between citizen and state.
The dream of citizenship becomes the nightmare of uncertainty.

Fear Wears a Flag

For many, citizenship is the crown jewel of belonging. It says: “I am one of you.” It says: “I belong here.” Yet, in this new American concoction, citizenship can now wear a flimsy label: “You belong until we decide you don’t.”
The news story notes that even those who thought they were safe are having nightmares: what if the state comes and says: “Change your status. We changed our mind.”
When the state stops being the guarantee and starts being the threat, fear becomes the new civic duty.

This is deeply political. The state that once promised permanence is now issuing caveats. Citizenship becomes “provisional,” not in oath, but in practice. Rights become conditional. Membership becomes revocable.
For diaspora communities, immigrants, people building lives — this is not just bureaucratic. It hits identity, security, trust.

Denaturalization as Policy, Denial as Identity

What does it mean when you can become a citizen and later have that right withdrawn?
It means the state holds the power of “belonging” in its hands like a bouncer at a nightclub. You’re admitted. You dance. Then the bouncer whispers: “Actually, we’re shutting the club. You – you’re out.”
And your citizenship certificate? The souvenir becomes the proof of what you used to be.

Such acts are not only legal maneuvers but symbolic messages: “We grant you membership, but you must remember: it is revocable.”
This sends a chilling signal to all who stood in line, filled the forms, waited the years: trust the state less. Participate less? Speak up less?
Fear becomes the invisible chain.

A Mirror for Somalia’s Diaspora? Why This Matters Beyond America

You and I may be far in theology — you in Puntland, engaged in civic identity projects — but this American story resonates for global citizens, for diaspora, for anyone building life across borders.

In Somalia, diaspora communities invest in homeland infrastructure; they regenerate lives. In the U.S., naturalised citizens invested in the American promise — homes, businesses, families — and find the ground shifting beneath them.
If citizenship is destabilised in the world’s most powerful democracy, what message does that send for fragile states, for people whose belonging has always been negotiable?

It underscores a global truth: when the state treats citizenship as a privilege rather than a right, another form of marginalisation creeps in.
You might hold documents. You might swear an oath. But your status is only as safe as the political convenience that underpins it.

The Big–Picture Politics: Fear as a Weapon

Let’s pull the curtain back. Why the fuss over naturalisation and denaturalisation? Because fear is power.
When people fear that citizenship can be taken away, they self-censor. They stop complaining. They avoid risk. They shrink.
That’s not a bug. It’s a feature. The state that casts the shadow of revocation over its citizens wields compliance without truth.
And let’s not forget: policies like this emerge in the broader context of immigration enforcement, securitisation, and the shifting politics of identity. The story of denaturalization is not only about immigrants. It’s about how states redefine loyalty, belonging, and consent.

The Punchline (But It Hurts)

So here’s the hard truth: In the land of the free, you might be free… until you’re not.
Citizenship was once the fortress of rights. Now it’s the house built on sand.
It doesn’t matter if you earned your certificate fairly, if you’ve lived the life of a citizen. If someone finds a thread in your paperwork, you can be un-made.

For those of us across the world watching this unfold — whether in Somalia, Puntland, or the diaspora communities of Kenya, Gulf, or Europe — it should raise alarms. Because if the U.S. can break this social contract, what hope do weaker states have for stabilising belonging?

Call to Action

If you hold citizenship anywhere: check your documents. Know your rights. Don’t assume permanence.
If you are part of the diaspora: worry not only about investment in infrastructure but about the investments made in identity — in belonging.
If you are a journalist, an editor, a civic educator: sharpen your voice. Denaturalization is the next frontier of disenfranchisement, the quiet removal of rights through paperwork and fear.

——–

Support WDM — the home of fearless, independent journalism that speaks truth to power across Somalia and the region. Tel/WhatsApp: +252 90 703 4081.