From Consultation to Congress: Puntland Must Rise to the Moment

EDITORIAL
Today’s all-day consultation convened by the President of Puntland State of Somalia, Said Abdullahi Deni, was not an ordinary meeting. It was a rare convergence of accumulated state memory: former cabinet ministers, ex-parliamentarians, veteran security commanders, and leading intellectuals—nearly one hundred minds shaped by war, peace, institution-building, and the hard lessons of Somali federalism. Such a gathering carries a responsibility larger than a communique. It demands elevation.
What unfolded in the Puntland State Presidency at outskirts of Garowe today was not merely “brainstorming.” It was a de facto congress—without the name, mandate, or legitimacy to match its gravity. And that mismatch matters.

Puntland at an Inflection Point
Somalia and the Horn of Africa are entering a dangerous phase: contested sovereignties, collapsing regional norms, external interventions masquerading as partnerships, and an increasingly erratic federal center. Puntland sits at the intersection of these storms—security pressures from extremist networks, constitutional overreach from Mogadishu, and geopolitical tremors from the Red Sea to the Gulf of Aden.
At such moments, process becomes substance. History teaches that decisions taken without broad legitimacy—even if correct—are easily delegitimized, resisted, or reversed. Puntland’s own founding in 1998 was not an executive decree; it was a grass-roots congress, painstakingly assembled to produce collective ownership and political durability (cf. Puntland State Formation Conference, Garowe, 1998).

Consultation Is Not Enough
A consultation advises power. A congress authorizes it.
The distinction is not semantic. Under Somalia’s federal dispensation, strategic actions—especially those touching security posture, inter-state relations, and constitutional interpretation—derive legitimacy from collective deliberation, not presidential briefings. This principle is embedded in the logic of the Provisional Federal Constitution, which recognizes shared sovereignty between federal institutions and member states, and—critically—between governments and their constituencies (Somalia Provisional Constitution, Arts. 1, 50).
By stopping at consultation, Puntland risks undercutting the very strategic clarity it seeks. Worse, it signals caution where confidence is required.

Why a Puntland Congress Matters—Now
Transforming this elite gathering into a Puntland Congress would do three essential things:

Anchor Strategy in Legitimacy
Decisions emerging from a congress carry moral and political weight that no executive statement can replicate. They bind institutions, unify elites, and reassure the public that Puntland is acting collectively—not reactively.

Reclaim Institutional Memory
Puntland’s veterans are not ceremonial figures. They are custodians of precedents forged through civil war, state collapse, and regional brinkmanship. A congress converts memory into policy.

Signal Readiness to Friends and Foes
In a region where perception often precedes power, a congress announces seriousness. It tells Mogadishu, neighbors, and international partners that Puntland’s next steps are not improvisations but the outcome of sovereign deliberation.

The Cost of Delay
Somalia’s tragedy is littered with missed moments—times when leaders chose expediency over institution-building. The result has been fragmentation, foreign manipulation, and perpetual crisis management. Puntland has long claimed to be different: rule-based, consultative, and grounded in consent.
This is the moment to prove it.
Elevating this consultation into a Puntland Congress is not a rebuke of the presidency; it is its completion. It would provide the President with a fortified mandate—one capable of sustaining difficult decisions in an unforgiving regional climate.

A Call to Courage
Great leadership is not defined by convening meetings, but by knowing when to formalize history. The brain power is already assembled. The issues are already grave. The hour is already late.
What remains is the courage to name this gathering what it truly is—and allow Puntland, once again, to lead Somalia not by noise, but by constitutional seriousness.

References (selected):
Somalia Provisional Federal Constitution (2012), Arts. 1, 50.
Puntland State Formation Conference (Garowe), 1998—foundational resolutions and communiqués.

——–
Support WAPMEN — the home of fearless, independent journalism that speaks truth to power across Somalia and the region.
Tel/WhatsApp: +252 90 703 4081.